This table forms part of a discussion on a flag (https://www.inaturalist.org/flags/542333#activity_comment_f72de246-215c-4f6b-be7a-7f3b2d0ca3d5), but was too large to post there: (Explanations of the justifications are in the flag)
Abbreviations:
Genera:
Palloptera=P, Toxonevra=X and Temnosira=M.
Sources:
SD - Systema Dipterorum
FE - Fauna Europaea
OZ - Ozerov, various papers
MZ - Merz https://www.e-periodica.ch/cntmng?pid=seg-001:1997:70::520
HYH - Han https://www.researchgate.net/publication/264147044_A_Checklist_of_the_Families_Lonchaeidae_Pallopteridae_Platystomatidae_and_Ulidiidae_Insecta_Diptera_Tephritoidea_in_Korea_with_Notes_on_12_Species_New_to_Korea/link/53d6230f0cf220632f3d872c/download
MC - Merz and Chen https://www.e-periodica.ch/cntmng?pid=seg-001%3A2005%3A78%3A%3A437
MS - Merz and Sueyoshi http://www.studia-dipt.de/con91.htm
Species | iNat | Proposed Genus | For | Against | Justification |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
albertensis Johnson, 1921 | N/A | P | Nearctic | N/A | Nearctic |
alticola Ozerov, 1994 | X | X | SD, OZ | N/A | Described by Ozerov - so could be Temnosira |
ambusta Meigen, 1826 | PM | M | FE, MZ | SD (P), OZ (X) | M not recognised by OZ |
anderssoni Rotheray & MacGowan, 1999 | P | P | SD, FE | N/A | Unanimity |
basimaculata Czerny, 1934 | N/A | X | OZ, FE, MZ | SD (P) | Discount SD when alone as (P) |
bimaculata Strobl, 1910 | P | P | SD, FE | MZ (X) | FE vs Merz - X not common |
carterosoma Ozerov, 1993 | X | X | SD,HYH, OZ | N/A | Described by Ozerov - so could be Temnosira - but HYH did not reassign |
claripennis Malloch, 1924 | P | P | Nearctic | N/A | Nearctic |
czurkini Ozerov, 1993 | N/A | M | SD | OZ (X) | M not recognised by OZ - one of two he says are difficult to place |
elegans Merz & Chen, 2005 | N/A | P | SD, MC | N/A | Unanimity |
ephippium Zetterstedt, 1860 | X | X | OZ, FE, MZ | SD (P) | Discount SD when alone as (P) |
flava Oldenberg, 1910 | N/A | P | SD, FE, MZ | N/A | Unanimity |
formosa Frey, 1930 | P | P | SD, OZ, FE, MZ | N/A | Unanimity |
gavryushini Ozerov, 2019 | N/A | X | OZ | N/A | Described by Ozerov - so could be Temnosira |
jucunda Loew, 1863 | N/A | X | Nearctic | N/A | Nearctic |
kloiberi Morge, 1967 | N/A | X | MZ | SD (P) | Discount SD when alone as (P) |
kukumorensis Czerny, 1934 | N/A | P | SD, MC | N/A | Unanimity |
laetabilis Loew, 1873 | X | X | OZ, FE, MZ | SD (P) | Discount SD when alone as (P) |
longipennis Czerny, 1934 | P | X | OZ | SD (P) | Discount SD when alone as (P) - Ozerov only - but he does not mention it as a difficult placement |
maculifemur Czerny, 1934 | N/A | P | SD, FE | MZ (X) | FE vs Merz - X not common |
marginata Meigen, 1826 | P | P | SD, OZ, FE, MZ | N/A | Unanimity |
modesta Meigen, 1830 | PX | X | OZ, FE, MZ | SD (P) | Discount SD when alone as (P) |
muliebris Harris, 1780 | X | X | SD, OZ, FE, MZ | N/A | Unanimity |
nigriscutata Ozerov, 1993 | N/A | M | SD | OZ (X) | M not recognised by OZ - one of two he says are difficult to place |
orientata Kovalev, 1972 | N/A | X | OZ, HYH | SD (P) | Discount SD when alone as (P) |
pallens Loew, 1873 | N/A | X | FE, MZ | SD (P) | Discount SD when alone as (P) |
paralia Ozerov, 1993 | N/A | X | SD, OZ | N/A | Described by Ozerov - so could be Temnosira |
quinquemaculata Macquart, 1835 | PX | X | OZ, FE, MZ | SD (P) | Discount SD when alone as (P) |
saltuum Linnaeus, 1758 | PM | M | FE, MZ | SD (P), OZ (X) | M not recognised by OZ |
scutellata Macquart, 1835 | P | P | SD, FE, MZ | N/A | Unanimity |
septentrionalis Czerny, 1934 | N/A | X | MZ | SD (P) | Discount SD when alone as (P) |
setosa Melander, 1913 | N/A | P | Nearctic | N/A | Nearctic |
shakhadarana Ozerov, 2010 | N/A | X | SD, OZ | N/A | Described by Ozerov - so could be Temnosira |
shatalkini Ozerov, 1993 | N/A | M | SD | OZ (X) | M not recognised by OZ |
similis Johnson, 1910 | N/A | X | Nearctic | N/A | Nearctic |
simillima Merz & Sueyoshi, 2002 | N/A | M | SD, MS | N/A | Unanimity |
striata Merz & Sueyoshi, 2002 | N/A | X | SD, MS | N/A | Unanimity |
subarcuata Johnson, 1921 | M | M | Nearctic | N/A | Nearctic |
subusta Malloch, 1924 | P | P | Nearctic | N/A | Nearctic |
superba Loew, 1861 | N/A | X | Nearctic | N/A | Nearctic |
terminalis Loew, 1863 | N/A | P | Nearctic | N/A | Nearctic |
trichaeta Ozerov, 1993 | N/A | M | SD | OZ (X) | M not recognised by OZ |
trimacula Meigen, 1826 | PX | X | OZ, FE, MZ | SD (P) | Discount SD when alone as (P) |
umbellatarum Fabricius, 1775 | P | P | SD, OZ, FE, MZ | N/A | Unanimity |
usta Meigen, 1826 | P | X | OZ, FE, MZ | SD (P) | Discount SD when alone as (P) |
ustulata Fallén, 1820 | P | P | SD, OZ, FE, HYH, MZ | N/A | Unanimity |
venusta Loew, 1858 | N/A | X | OZ, FE, MZ | SD (P) | Discount SD when alone as (P) |
Comentarios
Agregar un comentario